[@mo******uava9418
When people mention the lifestyle of medieval peasants they are generally referring to the extreme ways that industrialization changed life for everyone. It is well documented that quality of life for working people rapidly declined with the rise of industrialization. Quality of life was only partially earned back through labor union demonstrations and collective bargaining. Like it or not, along with real positive progress, there are also very clear ways that things have worsened over time for most people.]
[@Turd****son-z4m
2 days ago
So, some poeple go a bit overboard with nostalgia, therefore let's take the opposite position -- that way we'll seem so smart and so cool and cynical. Super sophisticated approach.]
[@Anti*****onFox
This video is almost as foolish as the people it makes fun of . Some things were better some things were worse .
Wages were still going up until the 70s when the oil crisis and overseas manufacturing growing changed our economy . idk why you're obsessed with proving Facebook boomers wrong to the point where you squint your eyes to find any figure that suits what you want to believe. Just like the people you ridicule]
[@os***iC
This video is trash. "1950s weren't perfect, therefore 1950's were worse than the present" is not a serious argument.]
The demystification point is valid on OP's part and yet also double-edged via hypocrisy, ergo his argument cannibalizes itself because it's hinged on the strawman that people didn't already know that every era has issues-
that humans in the 50s behaved like humans, that 50s marketing was indeed marketing, that a mascot is indeed a mascot. That a mascot is more of an ideal, than a realistic bar to reach and maintain.
TL;Dr: BritMonke criticizes narrow misrepresentation of the era via a narrow misrepresentation of the era.
Making the best of a 21st century state of the art sinking ship is not going to change the fact that progress is not inherently optimal/ good, even with good intentions or presumption of moral superiority.
And with the 21st century's objective improvements, that still doesn't invalidate the 1950s base positives.
Firstly::
Modernity patched most of what OP correctly complains about of mid-century ignorance-
and yet the independent, globally declining, legally better, better economic options, resentment ridden, over-politicized, distrusting, technologically marvelous, medically lucrative, gaslighting, hyper-individualist, blablabla negative modern stuff.
🚨ie. Presumptuous modern ignorance actually isn't the winning formula either.
The decline the 50s was already treading at a slower pace, with caveats- ironically In many ways modernity & progress accelerated that decline, Even WITH the objective improvements as a handicap.
🚨OP soft mentioned some modern bullets as he sped walked by them conveniently, not wanting to linger on the modern issues of the timeline. But he had nothing but receipts for the 50s, hence 97% of the video. 🤔Convenient shortcut.
Secondly::::
📌 We (general) are fully aware the perfect family mascot model was not perfect, yet the 50s family functioned, flawed, but functioned in parallel with basics, foundation. The seemingly sterile, mythic ideal that endured and built.
📌Just like the sterile, curated modern independent strong woman mascot who can have it all, do it all, her own self-interest is god 24/7
> adulthood is adulthood for men/ adulthood for women is labeled "second shift", always an excuse, always a scapegoat, externalization stats over 99+
> "toxic self-reliance" if a man/ "independence" if a woman.
>Collapsing under her own weight (eventually) from burden of modern rigid norms that puts way too much pressure on women to be her own worst interest.
Which somehow wont result in depression, loneliness, isolation, burnout, resentment, frustration, confusion or living in a therapist office habitually, or not be insufferable--
🚨And the worst part? Women themselves see the pattern, and the few know they're being played by their own allies via perpetual "Victimhood"
Put on your humanization lens, picture it: Plenty modern women say yay to their era's norm, naturally, current era is all we (male or female) know, just like the 50s predecessors.
This is correct society says the current. Prominent women in their 40s & 50s writing articles insisting to society that they are actually very happy travelling abroad for the 55th time this week and everything is totally fine, as if to convince us to convince themselves that nothing is missing.
They could actually just be harmlessly blog journaling, otherwise? Self-tell without self-telling. Cause that's a very specific thing to vent about, across so many, so consistently around a similar age bracket, then it sinks in. And the comments is just the icing on the cake, the feedback loop, the group hug effect.
Plenty have priorities, busy, occupied (which is how time leaves us) but how many are content & satisfied when things quiet?
You could say the same about the average to worst case scenario of 50s housewife, even the husband. Now how eerie is that? Two different realities, same pitfall. Only one had a theoretically reliable infrastructure.
TL;DR That caricature of 21st century ideals is performative, unrealistic, unhealthy, socially not viable, not perfect nor functional; 100% not how humanity got this far, because it's draining women & society dry and we're barely into the new century. It was an optimum shor term gamechanger, but a failed formula before it can even get warm, longterm.
📌Women's agency was the vehicle to get here but it wasn't the failed formula, the failure was it's socio- ideological, political appropriation / how women's agency was co-opted to push else everything else preceding it.
As objectively flawed as it were, mid-century America wasn't Sharia law, lets keep it in proportion.
- Because how OP presented the testimony of those housewives made me think they were murdered by their husbands or something, a very real concern, valid anecdotal evidence of the consequence of the time yet dramatized into some post-event fallout as if that wasn't a first world problem, which it is.
- Women can say the same today where they can have nothing but priorities are still know who they are. If the video did the work to validate the real concerns of then and humanize how similar they are to today despite the improvements to the same exact country, you bash the 50s less and then this becomes about how each era manifests a similar consequence at a different intensity.
You can do that in under 15-20 minutes of video and not trivialize either situation.
Point being:🚨50s or 2000s/2020s There are consequences to both, but one clearly has more drawbacks than the other. When there doesn't have to be sides, you can have both, optimized. 👈👈
✅That's what the 21st century is squandering to use the past to maintain moral hierarchy.✅
🚨 Now: take away the negative rhetoric & obfuscation and what you get is: 1. The Future is not female, it's family unit infrastructure.
and 2. women having the agency to own their direction in life is not a threat to civilization when & IF left alone by politics and unchecked ideology.
Get rid of the lenses, detox and it's very simple. Both pro and cons alike.
🚨Why is that stifling lore dump relevant? Because to Brit's credit, he concedes that how to "undo-" what happened is beyond the ability of his video.
But institutional arrogance Is not only part of many reasons why modernity is caving under it's own weight on basic level ZERO Human connectivity defecits (people still get together obviously, but it's made convoluted more than necessary)
If the moral grandstanders show humility, DEMYSTIFY themselves, then in theory, they become equals and then they lose their leverage to make demands as a moral superior. Zero accountability = guarantees society won't have a way to fix it at the source👈, let alone undo it if the usual suspects run free. 👈
******That's the point.
Thirdly::::
🚨We took the wrong notes from the 1950s to where we're outperforming it's decline but OUR nose is in the air somehow.
Positive note ✅One resolution can be compartmentalized communities, self-owned states of community. Maintain your own mini-villages. Which modern people do already even when they don't realize it.
#2 Unplug from statistics & peer study, the world outside shouldn't be canceled out because of a number you can't control.
(I can't stress that enough, especially to younger men and women.)
#3 quality of options for both sides have tanked immensely, but whatever standard you maintain for a partner? Meet it yourself. It helps.
TL;DR And I could type pages on the former but there's something attached to the complaint is the point. Offer me something tangible as you're preaching.
I'm a critic too, i get what BritMonke & all the others are trying to do in principle but enlightening people. But the approach is way off and it's hilarious given the irony.
1950s was flawed & human, got it. Many mid-century films made that clear already by often directly addressing the issues (ex. Adam's Rib 1949♂️♀️ Recommended)
My dental plan, my retirement plan, everything I like in media, my routine wouldn't be possible in the 50s. And to be an adult in the 50s means having to be born further back: PASS.
I can still respect the 50s, see it's problems without a tear down and 1000% see where progress went horrifically wrong since then & thus 50s were better by being far lesser.
🚨We're not better, We patched up the wrongs best we could, inherited issues, created more, expanded the worst & the consequences aren't through us yet.
We can express how good modernity can be and is, for whatever that's worth & be honest about it's unbridled failure. Not black nor white. It's gray, sloppy & intense.
✅The modern hypocrisy, counter-presumption of moral superiority, ego, zero accountability & resulting consequence vindicates precisely why ppl look back in the first place. Right back around. Full circle.
✅Video: A Good point, hypocritical framing, strawman fallacy premise. Good production value, horrible argument.🚨
( Nov-16-2026)











